Block Query 🚀

HttpClientGetAsync never returns when using awaitasync

February 18, 2025

HttpClientGetAsync never returns when using awaitasync

Asynchronous programming is a almighty implement successful contemporary .Nett improvement, enabling responsive and businesslike purposes. Nevertheless, utilizing HttpClient.GetAsync(...) with await tin typically pb to sudden behaviour, peculiarly situations wherever the call seemingly ne\’er returns. This tin beryllium irritating for builders, starring to blocked threads and unresponsive purposes. This station delves into the communal causes wherefore HttpClient.GetAsync(...) mightiness bent indefinitely and supplies actionable options to resoluteness these points.

DNS Solution Issues

1 communal perpetrator down a hanging GetAsync call is DNS solution nonaccomplishment. If the hostname offered to HttpClient can not beryllium resolved to an IP code, the petition volition stall indefinitely. This tin happen owed to web connectivity points, incorrect DNS server configurations, oregon typos successful the URL.

Troubleshooting this entails checking web connectivity, verifying DNS server settings, and treble-checking the URL for accuracy. Instruments similar ping and nslookup tin beryllium adjuvant successful diagnosing DNS issues.

For case, if your exertion is moving successful a containerized situation, guarantee the instrumentality has appropriate DNS configuration. Incorrectly configured /and many others/resolv.conf inside a Docker instrumentality tin pb to DNS solution failures.

Firewall and Proxy Points

Firewalls and proxies tin besides intrude with outgoing HTTP requests. If a firewall blocks the transportation oregon a proxy requires authentication, GetAsync mightiness ne\’er absolute.

Reappraisal firewall guidelines and guarantee that outgoing connections connected the required ports are allowed. If a proxy is active, configure HttpClient with the accurate proxy settings and credentials. Frequently, neglecting to configure proxy settings for HttpClient successful a firm situation tin origin this content.

See utilizing instruments similar Fiddler oregon Wireshark to seizure web collection and analyse if the petition is equal leaving your device. This tin supply invaluable insights into possible firewall oregon proxy interference.

Deadlocks and Synchronization Discourse

async and await key phrases simplify asynchronous programming however tin present deadlocks if not utilized cautiously. If GetAsync is referred to as inside a synchronous discourse that blocks the asynchronous cognition’s completion, a impasse tin happen, making it look arsenic if the call ne\’er returns.

To debar this, guarantee that GetAsync is referred to as inside an asynchronous discourse and debar blocking the calling thread. Utilizing ConfigureAwait(mendacious) tin aid successful any eventualities by stopping the continuation from moving connected the first synchronization discourse.

A communal illustration is calling GetAsync inside a UI thread’s case handler with out decently dealing with the asynchronous cognition. This tin frost the UI and artifact the GetAsync call from finishing.

Server-Broadside Points and Timeouts

Generally, the job lies not with the case however with the server. A dilatory oregon unresponsive server, web latency, oregon ample consequence sizes tin origin GetAsync to return an excessively agelong clip to absolute. Mounting due timeouts connected HttpClient is important.

Usage the HttpClient.Timeout place to fit a timeout for the full petition. This ensures that the call volition yet instrument, equal if the server doesn’t react inside the specified clip. Selecting an due timeout worth relies upon connected the anticipated consequence clip of the server.

See implementing retry logic with exponential backoff to grip transient server errors. This tin better the resilience of your exertion to impermanent web points oregon server overload.

  • Ever cheque DNS solution, firewall guidelines, and proxy settings.
  • Beryllium aware of deadlocks once utilizing async and await.
  1. Confirm Web Connectivity.
  2. Cheque Firewall and Proxy Settings.
  3. Analyze Codification for Deadlocks.
  4. Fit Due Timeouts.

Featured Snippet: A communal ground for HttpClient.GetAsync(...) hanging is an unresolved DNS content. Cheque web connectivity and DNS settings archetypal.

Larn much astir asynchronous programming champion practices.“Asynchronous programming tin importantly better exertion responsiveness, however it’s important to realize its nuances to debar communal pitfalls similar deadlocks.” - Adept Developer

[Infographic Placeholder]

  • Instrumentality appropriate mistake dealing with and logging to place the base origin of points.
  • See utilizing a devoted room for HTTP requests, specified arsenic Flurl, for simplified and much sturdy dealing with of asynchronous operations.

FAQ

Q: Wherefore does ConfigureAwait(mendacious) typically aid?

A: ConfigureAwait(mendacious) prevents the continuation of the async technique from moving connected the first synchronization discourse, which tin aid debar deadlocks successful definite situations.

Knowing the possible points and implementing the instructed options tin importantly better the reliability and responsiveness of your .Nett functions once utilizing HttpClient.GetAsync(...) with async and await. By addressing DNS issues, firewall and proxy configurations, deadlocks, and server-broadside points, you tin guarantee that your HTTP requests absolute efficiently and effectively. Research assets similar the authoritative Microsoft documentation connected HttpClient and articles connected asynchronous programming champion practices to additional heighten your knowing. Dive deeper into troubleshooting web points with instruments similar Wireshark (https://www.wireshark.org/) and research precocious subjects similar transportation pooling and DNS caching to optimize your HTTP case’s show. Retrieve to recurrently reappraisal and replace your codification to incorporated champion practices and code immoderate rising challenges successful asynchronous programming.

Stack Overflow is a large assets for troubleshooting circumstantial points.

Question & Answer :
Edit: This motion appears to be like similar it mightiness beryllium the aforesaid job, however has nary responses…

Edit: Successful trial lawsuit 5 the project seems to beryllium caught successful WaitingForActivation government.

I’ve encountered any unusual behaviour utilizing the Scheme.Nett.Http.HttpClient successful .Nett four.5 - wherever “awaiting” the consequence of a call to (e.g.) httpClient.GetAsync(...) volition ne\’er instrument.

This lone happens successful definite circumstances once utilizing the fresh async/await communication performance and Duties API - the codification ever appears to activity once utilizing lone continuations.

Present’s any codification which reproduces the job - driblet this into a fresh “MVC four WebApi task” successful Ocular Workplace eleven to exposure the pursuing Acquire endpoints:

/api/test1 /api/test2 /api/test3 /api/test4 /api/test5 <--- ne\'er completes /api/test6 

All of the endpoints present instrument the aforesaid information (the consequence headers from stackoverflow.com) but for /api/test5 which ne\’er completes.

Person I encountered a bug successful the HttpClient people, oregon americium I misusing the API successful any manner?

Codification to reproduce:

national people BaseApiController : ApiController { /// <abstract> /// Retrieves information utilizing continuations /// </abstract> protected Project<drawstring> Continuations_GetSomeDataAsync() { var httpClient = fresh HttpClient(); var t = httpClient.GetAsync("http://stackoverflow.com", HttpCompletionOption.ResponseHeadersRead); instrument t.ContinueWith(t1 => t1.Consequence.Contented.Headers.ToString()); } /// <abstract> /// Retrieves information utilizing async/await /// </abstract> protected async Project<drawstring> AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync() { var httpClient = fresh HttpClient(); var consequence = await httpClient.GetAsync("http://stackoverflow.com", HttpCompletionOption.ResponseHeadersRead); instrument consequence.Contented.Headers.ToString(); } } national people Test1Controller : BaseApiController { /// <abstract> /// Handles project utilizing Async/Await /// </abstract> national async Project<drawstring> Acquire() { var information = await Continuations_GetSomeDataAsync(); instrument information; } } national people Test2Controller : BaseApiController { /// <abstract> /// Handles project by blocking the thread till the project completes /// </abstract> national drawstring Acquire() { var project = Continuations_GetSomeDataAsync(); var information = project.GetAwaiter().GetResult(); instrument information; } } national people Test3Controller : BaseApiController { /// <abstract> /// Passes the project backmost to the controller adult /// </abstract> national Project<drawstring> Acquire() { instrument Continuations_GetSomeDataAsync(); } } national people Test4Controller : BaseApiController { /// <abstract> /// Handles project utilizing Async/Await /// </abstract> national async Project<drawstring> Acquire() { var information = await AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync(); instrument information; } } national people Test5Controller : BaseApiController { /// <abstract> /// Handles project by blocking the thread till the project completes /// </abstract> national drawstring Acquire() { var project = AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync(); var information = project.GetAwaiter().GetResult(); instrument information; } } national people Test6Controller : BaseApiController { /// <abstract> /// Passes the project backmost to the controller adult /// </abstract> national Project<drawstring> Acquire() { instrument AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync(); } } 

You are misusing the API.

Present’s the occupation: successful ASP.Nett, lone 1 thread tin grip a petition astatine a clip. You tin bash any parallel processing if essential (borrowing further threads from the thread excavation), however lone 1 thread would person the petition discourse (the further threads bash not person the petition discourse).

This is managed by the ASP.Nett SynchronizationContext.

By default, once you await a Project, the methodology resumes connected a captured SynchronizationContext (oregon a captured TaskScheduler, if location is nary SynchronizationContext). Usually, this is conscionable what you privation: an asynchronous controller act volition await thing, and once it resumes, it resumes with the petition discourse.

Truthful, present’s wherefore test5 fails:

  • Test5Controller.Acquire executes AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync (inside the ASP.Nett petition discourse).
  • AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync executes HttpClient.GetAsync (inside the ASP.Nett petition discourse).
  • The HTTP petition is dispatched retired, and HttpClient.GetAsync returns an uncompleted Project.
  • AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync awaits the Project; since it is not absolute, AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync returns an uncompleted Project.
  • Test5Controller.Acquire blocks the actual thread till that Project completes.
  • The HTTP consequence comes successful, and the Project returned by HttpClient.GetAsync is accomplished.
  • AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync makes an attempt to resume inside the ASP.Nett petition discourse. Nevertheless, location is already a thread successful that discourse: the thread blocked successful Test5Controller.Acquire.
  • Impasse.

Present’s wherefore the another ones activity:

  • (test1, test2, and test3): Continuations_GetSomeDataAsync schedules the continuation to the thread excavation, extracurricular the ASP.Nett petition discourse. This permits the Project returned by Continuations_GetSomeDataAsync to absolute with out having to re-participate the petition discourse.
  • (test4 and test6): Since the Project is awaited, the ASP.Nett petition thread is not blocked. This permits AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync to usage the ASP.Nett petition discourse once it is fit to proceed.

And present’s the champion practices:

  1. Successful your “room” async strategies, usage ConfigureAwait(mendacious) each time imaginable. Successful your lawsuit, this would alteration AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync to beryllium var consequence = await httpClient.GetAsync("http://stackoverflow.com", HttpCompletionOption.ResponseHeadersRead).ConfigureAwait(mendacious);
  2. Don’t artifact connected Projects; it’s async each the manner behind. Successful another phrases, usage await alternatively of GetResult (Project.Consequence and Project.Delay ought to besides beryllium changed with await).

That manner, you acquire some advantages: the continuation (the the rest of the AsyncAwait_GetSomeDataAsync methodology) is tally connected a basal thread excavation thread that doesn’t person to participate the ASP.Nett petition discourse; and the controller itself is async (which doesn’t artifact a petition thread).

Much accusation:

Replace 2012-07-thirteen: Integrated this reply into a weblog station.